I’m a blogger. This is what was written in Arab News today, the leading Saudi English paper in an article about women’s sports clubs here. Another thing that I’m not is a social worker. I’m a lecturer. I teach English as a foreign language and for specific academic purposes. But what I was really disappointed in was that the writer got my viewpoint all wrong. She asked me what I thought about religious people using the government to close down sports clubs. The issue being that these clubs are increasingly becoming popular with Saudi women. Women only sports clubs have been popping up everywhere and their fees are now within reach of the average woman. They offer aerobic classes, self-defense and even salsa dancing. However they have no legal licensing umbrella because according to the government all forms of exercise are for men only. So the owners of these clubs get a license for a salon or a child activity center and then expand from there. Ultra conservatives are dead against these establishments because they believe that they lead Saudi women to sin through the influence of and interaction with unsavory feminist and sometimes they go as far as lesbian women who work there and frequent the clubs (according to the muttawa sexually repressed wild imagination). Moreover they believe that exercise goes against femininity and that it is an exclusively manly domain.
In the eighties and nineties there weren’t many of these sports clubs around and if one does open, the muttawas would camp outside its doors and harass the owner and workers until it closes down out of frustration. Then these muttawas would preach about the sins that they uncovered and led to their victory in closing the club.
Now that they are all over the place and extremely high in demand the muttawas logistically cannot take the same approach. So what they are doing is taking a top down approach through bureaucratic nonsense. And that is what I meant by their reaction being natural. I do not support the government in closing them down but I do believe that licensing should be done properly. What the ultra conservatives are doing is futile because its too little, too late. It’s the same thing over and over again with satellite TV, camera cell phones, music stores …etc. The general public demands them too much for these conservatives to be able to stop their spread. And now they are taking on womens sports clubs which will only lead them to be legalized and taken off the black market into the light, just like their other “sinful” predecessors.
11 Comments
April 27, 2009 at 1:08 am
Is there any reason why clubs need licensing at all?
April 27, 2009 at 8:05 am
I noticed that Typo yesterday in the article! lol.
As for the main issue spoken about, its absolutely ridiculous that they are against female gyms opening. I don’t see any reason why it should be seen as a sin, if they are worried about lesbianism, there is enough in the education system… will they close down all the schools and universities in the country? Working out is something I LOVE, and being in an environment with other like-minded people makes it all the more challenging. I sure hope they begin and easier and more logic form of licencing for ladies gyms. Better yet, why not make it undergo what male gyms go under? That should be enough!
Thanks for sharing!
April 28, 2009 at 6:20 am
You’re not a bolger, you’re a Bolger. That’s like a title or something!
Maybe you’ve been blog-knighted!
-TFK
April 28, 2009 at 7:14 pm
“I am not a bolger!”
There was Ray Bolger (from the Wizard of Oz), perhaps the writer meant you were a dancer and actor! (I don’t really think so, but it is a thought).
April 29, 2009 at 4:25 am
to let others knows the other half or the story:
First:
the government closed the unlicensed women health clubs because they caught a prostitute at one of the unlicensed clubs( that was posted on one of the newspapers in saudi)
That was the real cause. The government didn’t close all the clubs ,but the unlicensed ones!
Secondly:
There is a law in the country; people must follow it. Business owners paid hunderds of thusands of Riyals to get licensed. It’s not fair for them to not close the illegal clubs.
Saudi law requires all the private women health clubs to be monitored by private or public health organizations. I mean here private hospitals, specialized clinics and so on.
Women are encouraged to go to licensed health clubs and practice their hobbies freely under the supervison of certified specialists and health doctors.
thanks for posting
April 29, 2009 at 7:29 am
the ‘finding’ of one prostitute in one unlicensed center doesn’t warrant a crack down on women exercising in general. Although I find it odd that they ‘found’ one prostitute in a ‘womans’ gym. Generally they service men don’t they?
The point is that mens gyms are NOT under supervision of ‘certified specialists’ and ‘health doctors’. Why are womens gyms treated differently? Simply because they don’t want them.
I’m all for proper business licensing but when a country continually discriminates against one gender than it is an issue for me. Not to mention the over all government status on women exercising to begin with. But I don’t think many men get that.
April 29, 2009 at 10:50 am
I’m sorry Suliman but you’ve taken being a Saudi apologist way too far. In which paper was there an article on catching a prostitute in a women’s exercise club?
A license for a women’s exercise club is non existent. There is no such thing as a a women’s sports club according to the government. This is a fact.
The only ones that are being spared are the ones that are part of a medical facility because they are used as part of physical therapy.
April 30, 2009 at 12:28 pm
Was the prostitute working out? or was she there with her pimp? or maybe she was offering her services to other women… hmmm
Sometimes, we are just so gullible that we believe anything without thinking.
What about the guy that said women that excersize and go out walking “have no shame” or those that follow sports and go to stadiums have not been raised well.
Keep on bolGering, maybe the writer was thinking of Bvlgari.
May 4, 2009 at 6:26 am
”A license for a women’s exercise club is non existent”.
there are some new changes but you got to wait to see them !
first step is to controll clubs then start again with a new criteria.
May 11, 2009 at 7:16 am
[...] klubów fitness dla kobiet jest… religijna policja. Saudi Woman na swoim blogu w artykule “I am not a bolger!” pisze: “[...] kluby te (fitness) są coraz bardziej popularne wśród Saudyjek. Siłownie [...]
October 25, 2009 at 9:50 am
O_o